Sign up for Interest or Login. Assessing income protection insurance. Comparing car insurance comprehensively. How money and credit are created. All about Open Bank Resolution.
Saving for a house deposit. Why use non-bank forex specialists. Ryan Greenaway-McGrevy probes what the Investor-State Dispute Settlement aspect of the TPPA really means. Posted in KiwiSaver March 08, - Partners with the Chapman Tripp law firm assess the decision and ramifications.
The original article is available here. The Financial Markets Authority FMA alleged that in ten instances in former Milford Asset Management trader Mark Warminger manipulated the trading of NZX market stocks in breach of the Securities Markets Act SMA. He was found in both cases to have manipulated the market by increasing the offer quote and price for the shares and maintaining them at a higher level than would otherwise have been the case and also, through these trades, creating a misleading impression of the price of the shares on the day.
This was New Zealand's first market manipulation case to come to trial. As Chapman Tripp has commented before see here and hereit was always going to present challenges because the small New Zealand market is particularly susceptible to concentration of ownership with relatively few broking firms and relatively few stocks that are actively traded by institutional investors.
The judgment is of significant interest to participants in the New Zealand market, both in the examination of the notoriously elusive legal elements that make up this prohibition and in the Court's treatment of the facts underlying the two alleged breaches that were upheld and the eight that were not.
The case was brought under section 11B of the SMA, the predecessor to the current prohibition on trade-based manipulation in section of the Financial Markets Conduct Act FMCA. Both sections prohibit any act or omission having the effect of creating a false or misleading appearance with respect to the extent of active trading, or the supply, demand or price for listed securities.
It is important to emphasise that the FMA was alleging civil, not criminal breach. The second requires proof beyond reasonable doubt.
The standard of proof in civil actions is the balance of probabilities, meaning that something is more probable than not. This was the approach applied by Venning J, but on the basis that the seriousness of the allegations is such that strong evidence is required to satisfy the standard. Market manipulation raises difficult issues about purpose, cause and effect, against the complex backdrop of market trading.
Justice Venning's careful and thorough assessment of the New Zealand provisions in light of overseas precedents will not quell debate but is significant in setting out an analytical framework for participants and advisers to distinguish between legitimate and illegitimate trading practices.
This can result in difficult questions about the relationship between purposes and effects. Noting that every trade has the potential to impact on the price of a security, the Court held that the purpose of the trade may be the key factor which distinguishes culpable manipulation from a trade made for genuine reasons.
Another factor potentially relevant in distinguishing manipulation is the legitimacy of the trading. Venning J noted that legitimate commercial activity can encompass purposes wider than simply to acquire at the lowest available price or to sell for the highest realisable price.
Examples of legitimate indirect or collateral motives can include price or volume discovery and positioning. In practice, the investigative trigger will involve uneconomic or otherwise anomalous trades or trading patterns.
To find objective evidence of manipulative purpose and effect where there is no direct evidence of a subjective intention to illegitimately move price, the court will often look for evidence of an ulterior purpose in those trades.
As is normally the case, this investigation was triggered by apparently anomalous trading patterns picked up in monitoring. In determining whether trades or trading patterns are manipulative, the market data are therefore significant, but the context of the trading is also important in establishing the legitimacy or otherwise of the purpose behind the trading.
This context could include the timing and content of communications among traders, but also for example the incentive effects created by underweight or overweight portfolio positions in a stock which might motivate 'window dressing' or the influence that screen prices might have on other larger transactions the trader entered into or was contemplating. These considerations lay behind the Court's findings.
After reviewing the evidence, Venning J was satisfied that the FMA had met the standard of proof in two of the ten causes of action. The FMA alleged that Warminger knew of market interest to buy substantial volumes of FPH shares in crossings before he made a series of smaller FPH purchases using Direct Market Access DMA and that the DMA trades were intended to increase and maintain the price for FPH shares at a higher level than would otherwise have been the case.
Warminger argued the DMA purchases reflected his position as a willing buyer for a stock he considered undervalued at that level. Venning J held that the purpose of Warminger's buying activity was to raise the price for FPH shares to a level at which he could sell volume.
As an experienced market trader, he would have known his trading would have the effect of creating a false or misleading appearance of the demand and price for trading in FPH stock. Similarly, contextual factors were important to the Court's analysis with respect to Mr Warminger's ATM trades. The trades were for an extremely small volume relative to the fund's holding and resulted in an increase in the last traded price of the ATM shares. Mr Warminger's explanation that these trades were an attempt to confirm volume were inconsistent with his stated assumption that Goldman Sachs held ATM shares in volume, given that he had declined to negotiate with Goldman Sachs for any such purchase.
As noted above, the market manipulation provisions in the SMA have been substantially replicated in the prohibitions contained in Part 5 of the FMCA. There is a notable difference, however, in the defence to the legally presumed categories of manipulation — matched orders and wash trades.
Venning J ultimately held that contending views about the legitimate purpose defence did not affect the outcome in the case because, if the trading was for a genuine or legitimate purpose, it is not likely to have the effect of creating a misleading appearance. This is likely to involve a different inquiry, although it is not clear it would yield any different result in most cases.
NZX is currently consulting on a proposed updated trading options market manipulation guidance note. Submissions can be made until 17 March The Court made two declarations of contravention against Mr Warminger and must separately anyone make money selling weed edibles whether a pecuniary penalty is appropriate and in what amount.
The FMA will reflect on whether it wishes to appeal the eight remaining alleged breaches and Mr Warminger will consider whether to appeal the two contraventions established.
If one appeals, the other would likely cross-appeal. The court's reasoning will provide a useful framework for the How to do 60 sec binary option broker upcoming guidance note on wholesale conduct. It may also create live forex xml feed magento blueprint for defining trade-based manipulation alleged under the FMCA's fair dealing provisions, which can also apply to unquoted financial products and are based on a similar underlying premise of conduct likely to mislead the market.
We welcome your help to improve our coverage of this issue. Any examples or experiences to relate? Any links to other news, data or research to shed more light on this? Any insight or views on what might happen next or what should happen next? Any errors to correct? We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment or click on the "Register" link below a comment. Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate.
We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will most important economic indicators forex those repeatedly making such comments.
Our current Comment policy is here. What that means in other language is "If the Bank But is the new Code too vague?
Chapman Tripp partners see the Mark Warminger decision on market manipulation as providing useful clarification of a difficult law | ysygohajavin.web.fc2.com
Wow for the first time I can remember the BNZ just sent me an e-mail about their term DEPOSIT interest rates. Is this a sign that the banks will Carlos67 on All housing affordability measures have their drawbacks, but all point to one policy response required, PM English says. It is long past the time when they should have solved Chris-M on All housing affordability measures have their drawbacks, but all point to one policy response required, PM English says.
It's the inability for anyone to take the bull by the horns.
Think about a modern progression of Gliding On. That is a lesson to the Cibc rrsp investment options Bear Hero on Alex Tarrant says we must cut the cost of supplying houses.
And that must feed through to lower house prices. It's simple economics, but not simple politics 2 billion for a new motor way 3. This will hurt their brains. The figures show just how far out of reach home ownership is becoming for aspiring first home buyers on average wages in Auckland. All news stories Opinion Top 10 column Economic calendar KiwiSaver news Personal finance news How the OCR is set Bonds news Currencies news Reported Job Losses.
Robo-advice could be round the corner. Rents have 'declined relentlessly' in Christchurch, says Trade Me Property. Typical Auckland 1st home buyers need more than 7 years to save a deposit.
How Labour's housing strategy hinges on foreign speculation. Little confident on regional work visas. Farm sales up, but lifestyle block prices flatten particularly in Auckland. Banks offer svelte new principles based Code of Banking Practice. The banking industry is seeking the public's views on its proposed new, dramatically thinned down, Code of Banking Home loan affordability reports Rent or buy Rent ratio House-price-to-income multiples Commercial property for sale Lifestyle blocks for sale Farms for sale.
Rental yield indicator Mortgage interest rates Mortgage calculator Fix or float calculator Mortgage omgeo trading system history chart Revolving credit rates Moving money overseas?
Is modular the answer? Goff wants builders not councils to be liable for shoddy work. How much housing is overpriced. Buyers is income earned abroad taxable in india in force at latest Auckland apartment auctions. Housing rents up strongly in Wellington, flat in Auckland and declining in Christchurch. Mortgage rates - Mortgage calculator Revolving credit Car loans Credit cards Personal loans Business fraud detection in stock market anomaly rates Mortgage calculator Fix or Float calculator Mortgage rate chart.
Westpac next to hike floating home loan rates. TSB Bank hikes floating home loan rates. Vulnerability of owner-occupiers to higher mortgage rates. Co-op Bank details credit card customer numbers.
Big drop in new lending to residential property investors. This time is special? Reconciling New Zealand's mortgage market. Westpac follows ANZ, hikes mortgage rates. TSB Bank strikes with hot 2yr mortgage rate. TSB Bank targets its firepower at the heart of the fixed rate market with a competitive offer at a time most banks are ANZ processing error hits 51, KiwiSavers.
Who Are Market Makers? by ysygohajavin.web.fc2.com
Can banks bolster deposit funding by increasing their interest rates? UDC investors offered 'success-based participation fee' for key takeover vote. Would-be new UDC owner doesn't expect higher funding costs. Two major banks change term deposit offer rates. Is a form of deposit insurance finally coming to NZ? ANZ changes a number of term deposit rates, mostly up.
The term deposit arm-wrestle. Banks are competing harder for term deposit funding, even as wholesale interest rates start slipping lower. Dean ruffles feathers Goldsmith didn't touch. How Rogernomics has favoured property investors. Shayne Elliott on why ANZ's pulling back from the universal banking model. The sharemarket manipulation case scrutinised. Our comprehensive review of default KiwiSaver fund performance to Marchidentifying who has the best long-term returns.
Stock trading courses in chennai rates Term deposit rates Dairy payout history Major Auckland projects Mortgage calculator Deposit returns calculator Farms for sale Lifestyle blocks for sale Commercial property. Bank leverage Live BUY currency rates Live SELL currency rates Bond prices KiwiSaver returns Understanding China Gold prices Sign-up for emails.
Assessing income protection insurance Comparing car insurance comprehensively How money and credit are created All about Open Bank Resolution Fixed or floating? Bernard's review Saving for a house deposit Why use non-bank forex specialists Credit ratings explained. The TPPA and investor-state disputes. Car cover Contents cover House cover Travel cover. Disability cover Health cover Home Income protection Life cover. How EQC's botch ups are coming back to bite Cantabs in the bum.
Policyholders need more protection. Big and overdue shift in insurance law looms. RBNZ can 'promote confidence' not 'protect policyholders'. Tower uses bank loan to stay afloat. Power imbalance between insurers and their customers to be tackled. Govt not committing to filling insurance regulatory gap flagged by IMF.
Commerce and Consumer Affairs Minister Jacqui Dean 'not in a position' to say whether claims handling will be Borrowing Saving Insurance Retirement Taxes Credit Cards QROPS fees How to Guides KiwiSaver Property. ANZ slashes incentives that encourage hard sell tactics.
Has the RBNZ missed the boat on DTIs? A guide to investing in index-tracking funds in NZ. TSB finally comes clean on Harmoney lending.
RBNZ says banks' high DTI data is 'erroneously high'. Seven ways to boost household savings. FMA keen to see personalised robo-advice enabled in New Zealand sooner than the law would otherwise allow.
Bull prices Weaner calf prices Cow prices Steer and heifer prices Beef local trade prices Dairy cow prices Dairy industry payout history Bobby calves Beef trends Beef grades Logs.
Dairy prices take first fall for three months. The rise of indoor farming and the demand for innovation. The Sheep Deer and Cattle Report. June log market report. Food could be our moon shot. Steady progress with Primary Growth projects. The Weekly Dairy Report: Milk auction falls for the first time since March but analysts still optimistic about next year. NZD best performing G10 currency. NZD awaits RBNZ announcement. Eyes on the US dollar.
Dairy saves construction's blushes - GDP weaker than RBNZ pick. Current account heading the wrong way Running out of positives. Spencer's RBNZ policy targets same as Wheeler's. NZD and local rates up. NZDUSD is back hovering around the 0. Commodities Confidence Credit Economy Exchange rates Interest rates Population Prices Real estate Rural. Mortgage calculator Fix or Float calculator Saving for a house deposit Where can I buy?
Credit card real cost Deposit calculator Buying foreign currency Compare NZ and AU income Business overdraft calculator. How to read these pages Current prices - NZ Government Stock - Senior bonds - Subordinated callable bonds - Redeemable preference shares - Convertible Bonds - Floating Rate Issues.
LATEST NEWS The great inflation rate debate. NZ Govt Bond tender number results. Get ready for adulthood. LGFA Bond tender 47 results. The return of the corporate bond. Success stories How to guides - The realities of growth - Achieving financial success Economic charts Borrowing interest rates Calculators Currencies Bonds Sign up for emails. Adrienne Duarte leaving BNZ to join Latitude Financial Services. Why NZ regulators must work closely with their counterparts overseas.
Labour leader Andrew Little confident regional skills visa will keep migrants in specific regions, won't be abused; Not You are here Home KiwiSaver Find your KiwiSaver fund. Chapman Tripp partners see the Mark Warminger decision on market manipulation as providing useful clarification of a difficult law Posted in KiwiSaver March 08, - The context The Financial Markets Authority FMA alleged that in ten instances in former Milford Asset Management trader Mark Warminger manipulated the trading of NZX market stocks in breach of the Securities Markets Act SMA.
Elements of market manipulation The case was brought under section 11B of the SMA, the predecessor to the current prohibition on trade-based manipulation in section of the Financial Markets Conduct Act FMCA. Evidence As is normally the case, this investigation was triggered by apparently anomalous trading patterns picked up in monitoring.
KiwiSaver Milford Asset Management Chapman Tripp New Zealand Super Fund Guardians market manipulation investment Superannuation private wealth asset management agreement Mark Warminger.
So this news is very welcome. You gave me a good idea for the topic of my essay. I would suggest anyone -including the authors of this article -if they want to know what Labour's housing policy is about that they should A quick glance through the Labour Party's website -housing section http: Oh my deepest apologies nymad for thinking the comments box was for comments. I reckon it went for almost 4mil. Just a little over the homes. You are right the Joneses and I think the same. The problem really is that some countries are more privileged than others.
It is nice to I agree, with the terraced housing and sections. But they need to be better designed houses. Quite frankly we don't need m2 4x2 houses Zachary, remember this listing at 36 St Vincent Avenue, Remuera? There is a big difference between travel and migration. I have no expectation of having free will to work or live long term in a different This has been staring them in the face for their whole tenure in government, i.
It's simple economics, but not simple politics. Don't tell the mortgage rate hike deniers. They offer an 8 month TD 'special' as a salve. And look at how the evolutionary process has worked out for them! To be fair, if you had to re-apply for your job with your employer every three years, even you wouldn't care about the long-term vision of the Kiwisaver news stream Latest news Most commented Most viewed Latest news Robo-advice could be round the corner.
Budget - Summary of all spending plans. A guide to buying property with mates. Most commented Robo-advice could be round the corner. Most viewed Robo-advice could be round the corner.
Home News Property Borrowing Saving KiwiSaver Insurance Personal Rural Currencies Charts Calculators Bonds Business.